July 11, 2008 - 9:15pm
Opinion

A House Divided

As labor is burning, our National union leaders are fiddling. Some of them are simply arsonists. While the labor movement has made tremendous progress in the past, every working American knows that we are facing exceptionally challenging economic times and a union movement that continues to decline. Everyone, that is, except for some national union leaders, who these days seem too focused on creating internal divides and engaging in selfish politics to focus on the fight for their members' rights.

This simply cannot continue. Whether it is the split of the national AFL-CIO unions into factions, or the tensions between public workers and building trades unionists in New Jersey, or National unions running roughshod over their own locals, it is a certainty that these ugly and unproductive divisions will choke what is left out of the life of organized labor. If we are going to make strides in critical areas like pensions and health-care , paid family leave and the right to organize freely, we must stop bullying each other. If we are going to win the fight against the unrelenting tide of givebacks and job loss, we must do so with one voice. As Abraham Lincoln once said: "A house divided against itself cannot stand."

This week, my Local and I, unfortunately learned this ugly fact firsthand when the national Communications Workers of America (CWA) staged a coup of our local’s offices and violated their own constitution to retaliate against our Local for our vocal and public opposition to the recent pension and benefits cuts and last year’s New Jersey state workers contract deal. Instead of engaging in a constructive and substantive debate about the best way to preserve and improve members’ benefits, our national leadership resorted to extreme and oppressive tactics to further their own individual agendas.

These tactics were on clear display when our National union stripped the members of our 16,000 person Local 1034 of their democratic rights. Our members democratically elected me, and my executive board, to oversee their union. But our National clearly decided that a democratic electoral process should not get in the way of their personal agendas and seized the building and the assets of our local and tried to remove me and my executive board from our elected position. They have drummed up a bunch of fictitious, false and baseless allegations to justify these ridiculous measures. They ignored both the union constitution and federal law, which call for notice, a hearing prior to taking action, a fact-finding mission and appeal rights. It is a travesty.

Unfortunately, our situation is not unique. Over the past few years, unions across the country have put internal politics and personal agendas above the interests of our movement as a whole. In 2005, unions left the AFL-CIO to form a splinter group, severely diminishing the union's influence and ability to create lasting change. We lost power, regardless of which side was “right” or had a better plan for reversing labor’s decline. At that time an organizer was quoted as saying: "A divided labor movement creates a favorable environment for those who seek to reverse pro-worker gains." And the national political climate could not be more anti-labor than it is right now happily capitalizing on those divides.

According to Barack Obama, Americans across the country are asking themselves daunting questions like "Will I be able to leave my children a better world than I was given? Will I be able to save enough to send them to college or plan for a secure retirement? Will my job even be there tomorrow? Who will stand up for me in this new world?" The labor movement should be at the forefront helping to find answers to these critical questions and electing Obama rather than spending energy beating each other up.

While the National CWA has locked us out of our local offices, they cannot and will not lock us out from talking with our members and meeting them at their workplaces. The members run this union, always have and always will. The leaders of our local are going to federal court to demand that the local be rightfully returned to its members and elected leaders. As elected leaders, we will continue to work tirelessly to protect and advance our members’ rights and we will not be silenced.

For the past 26 years, I have devoted my work life to the belief that the American labor movement is an essential part of our country’s core democracy and the key to economic prosperity for working people. We cannot make that a reality until we figure out how to stand together and stop burning down the house of labor.

Carla Katz can be reached via email at carla.katz@politickernj.com.

Related topics: Carla Katz, CWA

Comments

you are a disgrace


you really don't get it Carla do you. You can not spend the members money on politicans who you thing should get it. The members should decide. You used the local as your own piggy bank for favors and these same people can not help you now. Every election offical (man) you gave money to has dumped you. Your local gave money to Corzine opps!!! he gave that and more back to you. Even Cory Booker who can not walk and chew gum at the same time knew to take the locals money and your personal money and run, best move he has made as Mayor. You are a disgrace to the labor movement and as bad as CWA is as a union, they should have gotten rid of you a long time ago. Good bye for ever!!!!!

07/11/08 11:20 pm

Agree With Mr. Essex


Take the money and run. No woman is worth a 5 million dollar gift and more, unless there are many more e-mails and/or pictures of past events that are in your possession. To gain total support, release everything for your members to review and you'll have their total support. She mentioned Obama in statement and Mr. Essex mentioned Corzine and Booker. Many dues paying members are Republicans who really care about our State as do you. There are too many unanswered questions that need a better accountant of the funds that may have been pissed away to the Dems without union approval.

07/12/08 12:27 am

no


"According to Barack Obama, Americans across the country are asking themselves daunting questions like "Will I be able to leave my children a better world than I was given?"

no... simple as that...

thank you for screwing up the future generations...

The only difference between death and taxes is that death doesn't get worse every time Congress meets. - Will Rogers

07/12/08 1:09 am

A Few Anonymous Punks Casting Stones....


....does not impress me at all.

If the "coup" that Ms Katz refers to was, in fact, carried out in an illegal manner; that should be of relevance and concern to anyone who gives a damn about the rule of law.

What I hear from just about all of Carla Katz's critics on this site is simple ugly venom. You can't/don't/won't address the factual/logical points she made...so all you have left is vicious personal attacks.

America, and the world as a whole, needs organized labor if the quality of living standards is to be maintained and improved.

History teaches us that, left to their own devices, employers do all in their power to turn workers into becoming as close to slaves as they can get away with. That is evil; pure and simple.

Clearly, there are two radically differing versions of the truth in this case...and, eventually, the courts will have to sort it all out; but the sheer unmitigated ugliness of the attacks on Katz from the gutter of anonymity on this site make me want to be for whatever it is that you maleficent assholes are against.

From Frederick Douglass

If there is no struggle there is no progress......Power concedes nothing without a demand. It never did and it never will.

07/12/08 2:55 am

what?!!??


"History teaches us that, left to their own devices, employers do all in their power to turn workers into becoming as close to slaves as they can get away with. That is evil; pure and simple."

this state sucks my money dry... and spends it on 4 billion dollars worth of bs school building...

history teaches us what exactly?

The only difference between death and taxes is that death doesn't get worse every time Congress meets. - Will Rogers

07/12/08 3:07 am

JeffH, If There Were No Government To Protect...


 

...your "money" and I presume you also care about the rest of your rights, civil and otherwise; you would probably be dead right now as would most of us.

The main thing that stands between all of us a totally savage brutal existence where it's kill or be killed, is the existence of decent democratic governance.

Do I really have to make the case for you that human beings do much better when they form "more perfect unions"?

Try reading the Declaration of Independence and the US Constitution...and then give a look see to the UN Declaration of Human Rights! http://www.un.org/Overview/rights.html

The government you so detest is what protects your assets from anyone willing to kill you to take them away.

All you and people like you see is that you don't like paying taxes. That is a shallow and foolish perspective.

The answer isn't to abolish government, or unions for that matter, but to perfect them as much as possible over time.

The more humans beings learn to intelligently and lovingly co-operate with each other through culture and through the creation and enforcement of just laws; the better off we will all be.

For what it's worth, I agree that there is much that is corrupt in both government and in unions; but you must also acknowledge that the business sector is full of crooks and liars who screw with the laws in such a way as to diminish real competition and truly free markets.

In countries with little or no effective governance you have war lords running the place and hellish existences for just about everybody and low life expectancies for most. Is that the "freedom" you seek?

Or are you after having the kind of government they have in China where you can indeed get rich; but don't you dare think about political/personal freedom lest your body wind up in a plasticized display on world tour. http://abcnews.go.com/Blotter/story?id=4296699

 

 

From Frederick Douglass

If there is no struggle there is no progress......Power concedes nothing without a demand. It never did and it never will.

07/12/08 5:18 am

I'm glad...


... I don't have her nerve in my tooth.

07/12/08 9:50 am

Jimmy Hoffa Couldn't Have Said it Better


Every embattled labor leader has always raised the same arguments.

 

The best defense is a great offense.

We will see what the light of day and maybe a thorough audit, a Federal Investigation and the press bring out over the next period of time.

 

 

07/12/08 11:31 am

carla


As a reminder, here's what CWA National has found regarding the leadership qualities of Ms. Katz:

"The local spent money to send people to an April CWA conference in Washington, D.C., and to a June convention in Las Vegas, largely to support Katz's union vice candidacy."

"Katz worked only part-time as a local president while accepting a full-time salary. The reports says she worked only two to five hours per week from September 2004 to present while she attended law school." (I guess 2 to 5 hours per week meets the definition of "devoted my work life")

"Katz improperly gave more than $700,000 in political contributions without approval from the executive board, including $20,800 to Newark Mayor Cory Booker's 2006 campaign, even though only 36 Newark residents are 1034 members, and $77,000 to Bergen County Democrats, although less than 25 members work in Bergen County. "

So let's assume number of $25,000 for those trips, and about $300,000 in salary she collected while annoying everyone at Seton Hall, that's well over a million bucks she spent or accumulated for herself and her causes. Where'd that money come from? Union dues. Where do the union dues from govt. workers come from - public funds. TAXES.

And let us remember, she conducted back door negotiations with a $guy she u$ed to $date, which is despicable, even if the emails contain not one per$onal note.

Unions may be necessary for the protection of the worker, but honest leadership is necessary for the success of the union. It's the union itself that is seeking to correct this situation, not some conservative federal entity like, say, the US Attorney, although that may come.

This argument isn't about the validity of unions, it's about the validity of Carla's leadership. The state is barrelling down a road to bankruptcy, people cannot afford to live here, property taxes are going up again, pensions in the private sector are a distant memory, corruption (not just Carla's) remains rampant, and this person is writing romantic diatribes about the union movement.

It's an old ploy called the nobility racket - talk about how you are on the high road, how you would never do anything unethical, and hope your enemies will become distracted enough so you get the money. It's worked so far in her "career" I guess, but the national union is on to her.

07/12/08 11:38 am

Enough is Enough !!


C'mon Carla, haven't you fed long enough at the union trough ? How fattened do you really need to be? It's time to say goodbye and move on. Whether or not the allegations are true really isn't the issue at hand. The fact that you are shrouded in the shadow of inappropriateness and malfeasance is enough. It does not matter what is fact and what is fiction. What matters is what is perceived. Because of the negative perception that your actions now carry, you can no longer effectively lead the union. You have profitted very handsomely from your time in the sunshine. So, now it's time to follow the sunset and fade away into the future. Farewell !

07/12/08 12:39 pm

Good Job Wendy!!!


 

Your critique is, allegedly, fact based and not bitter, ugly or personal.

If the facts are as you say they are; then Katz and crew deserved to be canned.

What troubles me even more is the prospect that what both sides of this dispute are saying about each other may be 99% true.

We need good honest strong unions and to the extent that we don't have them, workers will continue to be shafted.

As it turns out though, people are still better off in a bad union than with no union at all.

The person who changes your grandmother's bedpan in the nursing home is as worthy of making a good secure decent living as anyone who is in CWA or the Teamsters or the MD who checks in for two minutes seconds and then bills 200 bucks for the hospital visit.

My sense is that the truth about all these allegations will be the subject of much public and legal scrutiny over the next year and that is a good thing.

 

 

From Frederick Douglass

If there is no struggle there is no progress......Power concedes nothing without a demand. It never did and it never will.

07/12/08 1:02 pm

You are a disgrace.....


.....first, you send illegal messages to your ex-boyfriend to get a better union contract (after you accepted millions and millions from him) and now you are caught using funds for your own personal gain.  Do your union and NJ a favor.....go away, you are pathetic.

07/12/08 2:29 pm

@Nick


there is a difference between a government which protects your rights and an all encompassing mass of who knows what... that we have now...

contrary to popular belief... you do not have the right to a new car or a big screen tv... you do not have the right to never be offended... you do not have the right to free food and housing... you do not have the right to a job... you do not have the right to happiness... etc...

The only difference between death and taxes is that death doesn't get worse every time Congress meets. - Will Rogers

07/12/08 6:02 pm

Judge Learned Hand


Dear Ms. Katz,

Congratulations for having gradulated from law school. Perhaps you are familiar with one of the most well regarded jurists in our history who never served on the Supreme Court, Judge Learned Hand. (You could not make up that name)

Judge Hand wrote, "a concept will expand itself until it tests the very boundaries of reason." Unions, have tested that boundary at their peril. I thank unions for the five day work week, the 40 hour work day, sick days, even paid leave. What I do not thank unions for is the concept of legitimate mediocrity. And that mediocrity has been largely underwritten at the publics expense by political expediency.

You write "we lost power, regardless of which side was 'right'." I would submit to you that getting it right does count for something. In politics getting it right can mean the difference between life and death. To reduce "right" to an illiteration is like calling our constitution just another document. Might will not always make right.

As I think of it your case makes the perect argument for public financing of campaigns. We need to get all the special interests out of our government. It is literally killing US.

07/13/08 7:47 am

Waaah!


My 15 minutes is up! How will I afford my mortgage and pay for my children's schooling and maintain a condo in Hoboken? Oh wait... Sorry. Girl, don't go away mad; just go away!!!

07/13/08 8:34 am

Double Post Deleted n/t


 

07/13/08 2:08 pm

Straw Man Arguments


I know of no one arguing that large "screen TVs" etc are things to which all people should have "rights".

Face it, the Limbaugh/Bush/McCain Republican world view is based on not much more than pure materialistic greed and egoistic selfishness.

I agree with you that Dems are far from perfect; but at least we have ideals that are, at the core, based on common human decency.

I don't see anything much except ugliness behind what people like Bush and his enablers stand for.

This is about so much more than anyone's stupid little tax bill.

From Frederick Douglass

If there is no struggle there is no progress......Power concedes nothing without a demand. It never did and it never will.

07/13/08 2:06 pm

How about.....


"This is about so much more than anyone's stupid little tax bill."

How about huge, overwhelming, ever-increasing, blown on wasteful rat holes, making people move out of the state, tax bill?

That's sound more like it....."little", I think not.....

07/13/08 2:46 pm

Throw her the hell off here


Yo Carla. You big mouthed, conniving, ass kissing opportunist. When the hell are you going to get it. WE DON'T WANT TO HEAR YOU. Any sane person in this State couldn't care less what you think. We sure don't want to hear it. 

WHEN ARE YOU GOING TO SHUT UP AND SLITHER AWAY.  I know, when the governor pays you another couple millions $$$$$$$$$$.

 And when is PolitickerNJ going to stop giving this gold digger a forum?

07/14/08 2:10 pm

Oh Lord


So exactly how are you related to Carla Katz?

07/14/08 2:14 pm

SomersetRepublican I Didn't Mean "Little" in The ....


....merely quantitative sense. I heartily acknowledge that tax bills are too high and that much of the money is wasted.

We're about to go into the hole for more hundreds of billions of dollars to bail out a real estate/banking industry that cashed in on a bubble they promoted...and now, along with Bear Sterns, we have the notion of being "too big to fail".

Most of the corruption/waste in government that rightly turns you off so much is in service to some element of the "private" sector that has bribed (legally or otherwise) someone in some way.

Just about every business interest lobbies and "contributes" to pols to "have their way" with taxpayers and consumers.

Maybe you should join me in calling for fundamental root to branch campaign finance reform that would eliminate the problem of legalized bribery?

Giving union members living wages, security and decent benefits isn't what's driving Nj and the whole country into the hole of unsane debt; it's the corporate welfare that makes the already filthy rich even more rich.

That's the thing about greed and power lust. It can never be sated.

btw Edmac, The misogynistic hatred here toward MS Katz (from some here) is truly amazing. Simply throwing nasty invective doesn't make your case; quite the contrary.

Time will tell if Katz is the victim of an illicit/ugly orchestrated campaign to discredit her or if she's some kind of wicked wacky louse.

Meanwhile, the Katz critics would have some more credibility if they would use their real names. Eh?

From Frederick Douglass

If there is no struggle there is no progress......Power concedes nothing without a demand. It never did and it never will.

07/14/08 11:16 pm

what??


per nick

"I agree with you that Dems are far from perfect; but at least we have ideals that are, at the core, based on common human decency.

I don't see anything much except ugliness behind what people like Bush and his enablers stand for."

1 - who said i like bush?? he's horrible...

2 - common human decency can not be forced... even with my mediocre living, i probably donate to more causes than you... however i certainly don't want a government to force me to do this... but that is exactly what you are doing...

and... if the state would stop taxing people like me to death, i could donate more... but at this point my wife and i are considering selling our home and moving out of the state...

our towns state aid was cut nearly 30%, so i can already see my property tax going through the roof...

thanks... merry x-mas to you too...

The only difference between death and taxes is that death doesn't get worse every time Congress meets. - Will Rogers

07/18/08 9:04 pm

In evry's one's life a little truth must fall


Even in Carla's. While she has spent much of her 26 years in the labor movement, disenfranchising,manipulating, isolating, and lying to the same Union members she so desperately wants to come to her rescue, she has some valid and factual points.

Much of her recent troubles w/National Union has been spurred by some very nasty and personal vendettas. She has long been the envy of many of her collegues. Though i am not quite sure why.

She is not the only CWA local president to use their local as personal theifdoms and to carry out their petty dramas. What she is accused of is buisness as usual in CWA. (Take it from some one who knows) Why the National stepped in this time? She opposed the contract, she took the national to court. That contract did not help Union Members. They gave away the store without putting up much if any fight. That contract will have severe implications for Union members for years to come. Not to mention, other State Worker contracts outside of CWA
She exposed them and pay back is a B*&^%. Much like what she has done to her own Union members who attempted to expose her she is out on her bony tush. So be it. HURTS DON'T IT CARLA?

07/25/08 8:28 pm

JUST GET OUT!


Carla, It's time for you to get out. You are a lier and a dishonorable person. You have let down your union. Your personal behavior is disgusting. You have slept your way to the TOP, got paid $6Million for your efforts and now you want justice??
JUST GET OUT.

07/27/08 9:36 am

The 12 Million Dollar Woman


Everyone thinks she got about 6 mil. Well, it is between 12 and 15 mil and a full ride for her kids through college.

Watch her hair frizz even more after she reads this post. Black Widows have nothing on Karla

08/14/08 12:08 am